Meet Kiera Tuttle

With more than 15 years in the insurance industry, Kiera Tuttle founded Confidence Insurance with a clear purpose: to make insurance feel personal again.

Kiera wanted the freedom to take care of clients her way—without corporate red tape, endless runarounds, or the frustration of never being able to reach a real person. Confidence Insurance was built to be a one-call insurance agency: with quick replies, honest answers, kitchen-table conversations, a little humor sprinkled in, and support that actually supports.

A lifelong learner and self-proclaimed overachiever, Kiera holds an MBA and enough insurance designations to create a small bowl of alphabet soup after her name. She is licensed in all 50 states and has experience across personal lines, commercial lines, specialty insurance, flood, and life insurance.

Through a broad network of insurance carriers, Kiera can explore multiple options and build coverage around each client’s actual needs. She believes people deserve to understand what they’re buying, why they need it, and who they can call when something goes wrong.

Beyond insurance, Kiera is a proud New Hampshire native who grew up on a small farm. She is not someone who sits still well. She’s a Justice of the Peace, Notary, ultra-endurance athlete, gardener, thrifter, DIYer, mini-bike enthusiast, and self-proclaimed comedian. She takes pride in living life loud, full, and in color. Passionate about philanthropy and community involvement, Kiera remains deeply connected to local nonprofits and causes that support her community and our nation’s heroes. She brings that same energy, determination, and grit to protecting her clients as she does to everything else in life.

Her philosophy is simple: make insurance approachable, make it transparent, and make it just a little more fun.